Home » Featured, General

A Disadvantage of Training in a Karate Uniform

9 November 2009 1,203 views 4 Comments

Ok, call me old fashioned, I like wearing a uniform in class I really do… however for practical purposes it’s useless. Certainly life and death survival does not depend on you wearing a Karate uniform.

The Karate uniform, or “gi”, emerged over time to establish a sense of uniformity among students in dojo. And as it resembles traditional garb of the time in Japan (when it first came into use); it could easily be viewed as practical or normal wear for that early period. Although it is accepted as the standard in clothing for practice, it does have a very real disadvantage.

The “gi” is very different from what you wear outside the dojo. While many simply take up Karate as a sport, most people do it as a means of learning how to defend themselves. A gi is designed to allow for freedom of movement and to handle the rigors of physical training. There are even designs available now for specific body types.

However if a real situation should arise, how likely will it be that you are walking around in non-restrictive garb? Depending on your gender, you may be in a dress and heels, or you may be in a slightly restrictive business suit. Even jeans and a belt limits trunk movement!

How would the clothes you are wearing now limit your movements? Would you still be able to defend yourself when your usual full range of body movement is restricted?

What’s the point?

Simply if you do not prepare yourself for defensive movement in ‘real’ clothing, you may find yourself severely limited at a time when you need to be in total control.

This is the major issue I have with training in gi; and in a dojo for that matter – how well are you prepared for the ‘real’ outside environment? Can you function; can you defend yourself and loved ones in your everyday clothes?

While the traditional Karate gi is a convenient, durable set of training clothes…. It does not allow you to experience being held back by your clothing; something you really need to try out!

Think about this for a second, we train night after night performing the wa-uke block; we finish the block with the grab and pull….. What are students typically pulling on? That’s right the sleeve of the Karate gi (instead of the arm). … SO if I am wearing a t-shirt then this method of control is nullified right?

How often do you train variations of this technique to allow for everyday clothing?

I prefer to train in my backyard, in the clothes I have on at that time. I also enjoy formal dojo practice however. It is controlled and much easier to work on correct form & technique. That being said I work the same material in regular clothes (a lot) to be sure I can move the same should the need arise.

When was the last time you practiced in jeans and sneakers?

  • Share/Bookmark

4 Comments »

  • Richard Bennett said:

    Personally, I do not see much disadvantage in wearing a karate unifor to trainm, considering that there is such a variety of clothing to be worn – I see it impossible to properly train for each possible scenario anyway. I have always trusted traditional karate systems, and believe that if you train properly during class, you could potentially avoid such problems. For example, if students are caught grabbing uniforms after a circle block, it might be indicated that one does not actually grab the uniform but the arm or more precisely, a hand full of skin. Considering that in Uechi Ryu, we train our grip with many instruments such as the Sanchin jars, grabbing the body is inevitable.

    Historically speaking, the karate uniform was clearly not always worn during class…and as seen in many old Uechi Ryu pictures, they barely wore anything at all at times. After training in Okinawa a few times, I definitely understand why. So, with this in mind, I am not necessarily trying to defend the wearing of karate uniforms or not, but simply that the knowledge of what a circle block, grab is all about, and the ability to maneuver around the opponent regardless of circumstance is really what matters. This goes for any martial arts technique however.

    I wear clothes that fit me well, so I do not have a problem fighting with what I have on…and for the ladies….gotta get rid of those high heeled shoes the minute something goes wrong! A dress might be better to train in than a karate uniform on, but I’ll have to settle with the hakama :(

    Big fan of this website ^^

  • Summer in South Africa – Sutra Magazine Shows Us How! | Fashion Style Advice said:

    [...] A Disadvantage of Training in a Karate Uniform | The Uechi-ryu Journal [...]

  • Robb Buckland said:

    In TMA we train in a gi for traditions sake , to celebrate our history and that of the founders . The gi should merely be one of our uniforms ….the other ones are already in your drawers or hanging in your closet !! : )

  • topblog » Karate Uniform said:

    [...] … Written by darrellguy1964 in: Karate Uniform | Tags: Karate Uniform, life and death, survival [...]

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.